loader
murder mystery 2 values

Murder Mystery 2 Values: How Knife Worth Is Actually Decided

Murder Mystery 2 Oct 21, 2026 Agent-api assisted

Murder Mystery 2 has no official price list. This guide explains the three forces that actually set a knife's value, shows you how to price a trade in under a minute, and flags the scam patterns that target new traders.

Murder Mystery 2 official cover art

Murder Mystery 2 has been running since January 2014 and has passed 31.3 billion visits with more than 24.5 million favorites. The official page puts it plainly: "Collect and trade hundreds of knives!" What it does not give you is a price list — and that is exactly why "murder mystery 2 values" is one of the most searched MM2 phrases on the internet.

Why there is no official value list

Nothing in the game assigns a number to a knife. The trade window shows you what the other player is offering and nothing else. Every value list you find off-site is a community estimate that somebody maintains by hand, which is why two lists can disagree by 20% on the same item. Treat any single number as an opinion, not a fact.

If you are new to the roles behind those knives, start with the Murder Mystery 2 wiki: roles, maps and the knife collection — Innocents run and hide, the Sheriff is the only player who spawns with a weapon, and the Murderer has to eliminate everyone without getting shot.

The three forces that set a value

  • Rarity tier. How the item was originally obtainable. Anything tied to a limited window (a holiday event, an old season, a retired crate) has a hard ceiling on supply, because no new copies can ever enter the game.
  • Demand. Two items of identical rarity rarely trade the same. A knife that looks good in first person gets asked for constantly; an equally rare one that nobody wants sits in inventories. Demand is the half of the equation that moves week to week.
  • Condition of the market. When a big update lands, attention shifts and older collectibles soften. Right after an event ends, the items from it usually spike.

Value is roughly rarity × demand, with the event calendar acting as a multiplier on top. That is why "how rare is it" alone never answers "what is it worth".

Pricing a trade in under a minute

  1. Count the offer in a common unit. Pick one widely-held middle-tier knife as your yardstick and express both sides in it. This is the single move that stops you from losing a trade you felt good about.
  2. Check two independent lists, not one. If they disagree by more than roughly a fifth, you are holding an item whose demand is in flux — price it conservatively.
  3. Separate "rare" from "wanted." If you cannot find a buyer in two sessions, the item is rare but not liquid. Lower your asking price rather than waiting indefinitely.
  4. Walk away from urgency. "Trade now or the offer expires" exists only to stop you from checking.

The mechanics of the trade window itself, including what the game does and does not protect you from, are covered in Murder Mystery 2 trading: how the knife economy works.

Scam patterns to recognise

  • The switch. The offer changes in the final second. Re-read the window before you confirm, every time.
  • The two-step. A "free gift" first trade builds trust so the second one looks routine.
  • The external link. Any site that asks for your password or a "verification" step is not trading with you.
  • The fake middleman. Nobody outside the trade window can enforce anything.

Weapon rarity is graded separately from knife value — see the Murder Mystery 2 tier list of weapon rarity tiers if what you actually want to know is which gun to equip rather than what to trade.

Where to go next

Value-tracking is the same problem in every Roblox trading economy: supply is capped by old events, demand is a mood, and no developer publishes a price. The Strongest Battlegrounds values and character tiers break down the same way. For the live stats and the rest of our MM2 coverage, open the Murder Mystery 2 game page, or browse more Roblox action and combat games.