Upvotes and downvotes are the only explicitly opinionated numbers on a Roblox game page, and the ratio between them is a surprisingly readable signal. Absolute upvote counts mostly track how many people played, so they tell you about reach. The ratio strips reach out and leaves something closer to sentiment: of the players who bothered to register an opinion at all, how many were positive? Across the 41 games in the directory, 154,065,506 upvotes have been cast against 18,197,854 downvotes.
| # | Game | Upvotes | Downvotes | Ratio |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Anime Dice | 540,799 | 3,765 | 143.6 : 1 |
| 2 | Slayers 2 | 909,777 | 19,461 | 46.7 : 1 |
| 3 | +1 Speed Keyboard Escape | 9,896,937 | 318,832 | 31.0 : 1 |
| 4 | +1 Loot To Forge | 125,152 | 4,175 | 30.0 : 1 |
| 5 | Ride A Pet | 382,131 | 12,972 | 29.5 : 1 |
| 6 | Build An Ant Empire | 32,632 | 1,266 | 25.8 : 1 |
| 7 | Steal ASMR! | 15,470 | 785 | 19.7 : 1 |
| 8 | Build the Pyramid! | 89,692 | 4,613 | 19.4 : 1 |
| 9 | Launch a Lucky Block | 3,226 | 169 | 19.1 : 1 |
| 10 | Pet Simulator 99 | 3,068,713 | 170,450 | 18.0 : 1 |
Anime Dice leads with 143.6 upvotes for every downvote — 540,799 against 3,765. Slayers 2 is second at 46.7 to one and +1 Speed Keyboard Escape third at 31.0 to one. What the top of this table has in common is not genre or size but specificity: these are games with a clear promise that they deliver consistently, which is exactly the condition under which players rarely feel the need to register a complaint.
At the other end, Adopt Me records 0.4 upvotes per downvote, and Tower Of Hell records 2.8. Read that carefully before drawing conclusions. A low ratio in a very heavily played game is not the same as a low ratio in a small one — a game with millions of players attracts every conceivable grievance, including from people who never liked the genre and clicked through anyway. Tower Of Hell illustrates this: 4,363,397 upvotes against 1,565,174 downvotes is a ratio of only 2.8 to one, and it is one of the most-played games on the platform.
The honest reading is that the ratio tracks controversy more reliably than quality. Games that make players compete against each other, games with tradeable economies where people can be scammed, and games with aggressive monetisation all attract downvotes from players who would never have voted at all if the experience had been neutral. A middling ratio on a huge game often means nothing more than a huge audience.
Three biases distort this number systematically. Selection bias: only players who feel strongly vote at all, so the silent majority is invisible. Recency bias: votes cluster around launches, updates and controversies, so a game's ratio can shift sharply after a single bad patch. And audience mismatch: players who wandered in from a trending list and disliked the genre will downvote a game that its actual audience loves.
That does not make the ratio useless — it makes it a measure of consensus rather than quality. A game with a very high ratio is one where almost nobody who played it disliked it, which is a real and useful property. A game with a low ratio might be broken, or might simply be divisive, and the difference shows up in the comments rather than the numbers. If you want the safer signal, combine this with the live player table in our concurrent player snapshot. Games that are both busy and well-rated, like the one covered in the Blox Fruits guide, are the ones where the signals agree.
One more practical note: vote counts are cumulative and permanent just like visits and favourites, so a ratio set during a bad launch year can persist long after the problems were fixed. Check the simulator games on BloxBus section for examples of games whose ratios have barely moved in years while the games themselves changed considerably. The same persistence works in the other direction: a game that launched smoothly keeps a flattering ratio long after the experience has degraded.
On its own the vote ratio is a weak signal, because it measures the opinions of the small minority of players who vote rather than the whole audience. It becomes useful in combination. A game with a high ratio and a large live population is a safe bet — plenty of people are playing and very few of them disliked it. A game with a high ratio and almost nobody playing is probably a small, self-selected audience that loves something niche, which can be a wonderful discovery or a complete waste of an evening depending on your taste.
The genuinely informative cases are the mismatches. A game with a poor ratio but strong concurrency is divisive: many people play it and a meaningful share of them dislike it, which usually means aggressive monetisation, a punishing difficulty curve, or a competitive scene that generates bad feeling. A game with an excellent ratio and weak concurrency is a hidden gem or is simply too new to have been found. Neither reading is certain, but both are far better than treating any single column as a verdict. The full directory context is in the favourites versus live players breakdown, and for a concrete example of a divisive-but-popular title see the Tower Of Hell guide.
Does a low ratio mean the game is bad? Not necessarily. It often means the game is popular enough to attract people who do not like its genre.
Why do some games have almost no downvotes? Small, self-selected audiences rarely bother to register a negative opinion.
Can the ratio change over time? Slowly. Both counters are cumulative, so a bad first impression takes a very long time to dilute.