loader
Game Reviews

Roblox Favorites vs Live Players: Why the Two Rankings Differ

Oct 05, 2026 Game Reviews
Roblox Favorites vs Live Players: Why the Two Rankings Differ

Roblox exposes two numbers that look like they measure the same thing and absolutely do not. Favorites is a permanent counter: every player who ever clicked the heart button on the game's page added one, and it never goes down. Players online is a live gauge that swells and drains by hundreds of thousands over a single evening. Rank games by one and you get an answer to "what did people love?" Rank them by the other and you get "where is everyone tonight?"

Here is the BloxBus favorites leaderboard, taken from the same single sync on 5 October 2026 at 04:01 UTC that covered all 41 tracked games, with each game's live rank beside it. The last column is the interesting one: it is how many places a game falls when you switch from the favorites chart to the online chart.

#GameFavoritesLive rankPlayers onlineTotal visitsRank gap
1RIVALS93,886,2801083,34718,539,158,784+9
2Brookhaven30,331,9582234,35188,253,380,3750
3[๐ŸŒ—] Steal a Brainrot29,485,7411276,87273,818,698,818+9
4Murder Mystery 224,355,1604133,71131,055,698,0730
5Blox Fruits20,028,0815132,80164,820,861,4930
6Jailbreak18,675,985375,9718,065,145,762+31
7MeepCity14,763,5494112416,278,438,230+34
8Blade Ball12,986,3393114,1066,468,715,933+23
9Piggy12,256,8663413,41714,393,446,946+25
10Tower Of Hell12,025,7633214,07829,062,719,517+22
11Arsenal11,519,641393,2046,310,863,378+28
12Grow a Garden11,436,2413016,46935,956,651,863+18

One game is three times ahead of the field

RIVALS leads with 93,886,280 favorites โ€” about 3.1 times the 30,331,958 of Brookhaven in second place, and more than the bottom eight games on this list combined. Yet at the moment of the sync only 83,347 players were actually in it, putting it at number 10 on the live chart. It has 18,539,158,784 lifetime visits, so this is not a fading title; the favorites figure reflects a very large historical player base, and the live figure reflects an evening where other things took the crowd.

The games that peaked and stayed peaked

Three titles sit at the same position on both lists, which is rarer than you would expect. Brookhaven is number 2 on favorites and number 2 live, with 234,351 players online against 88,253,380,375 lifetime visits. Murder Mystery 2 matches at number 4 on both, with 133,711 live and 31,055,698,073 visits. Blox Fruits is number 5 on both, at 132,801 live and 64,820,861,493 visits. When a game agrees with itself across a cumulative metric and an instantaneous one, you are looking at a title whose current popularity is genuinely backed by long-term attachment rather than by a spike. Murder Mystery 2 is a good example of the genre side of that โ€” our roleplay games on BloxBus page collects more titles in that family, and the Brookhaven guide covers the one sitting at the very top of both charts.

Where the gap gets extreme

Now for the games people clearly loved once and are not playing right now. Divide favorites by current players and the numbers stop looking like rankings and start looking like history.

  • MeepCity โ€” number 7 on favorites with 14,763,549, but number 41 of 41 live: 124 players online. That is roughly 119,061 favorites per person currently in the game, and a 16,278,438,230 visit lifetime total that still ranks number 10 all-time. The largest gap on the board, at 34 places.
  • Jailbreak โ€” 18,675,985 favorites at number 6, only 5,971 players live at number 37. Gap: 31 places, or about 3,127.78177859655 favorites per live player.
  • Arsenal โ€” 11,519,641 favorites, 3,204 live. That is the second-largest favorites-per-live ratio on the list at roughly 3,595.
  • Piggy โ€” 12,256,866 favorites, 13,417 live.
  • Blade Ball โ€” 12,986,339 favorites, 14,106 live.

None of these are bad games. They are games whose audience arrived, played hard, and moved on โ€” which is the normal life cycle of a hit. A favorites chart frozen in time will always flatter them, because the counter cannot decay. Treat a huge favorites number with a tiny live number as a statement about the past, not a recommendation about tonight.

The seasonal middle

Between those extremes sits a group where the lifetime totals are enormous but the live crowd is moderate. Tower Of Hell has 12,025,763 favorites (number 10) and 29,062,719,517 visits (number 7 all-time), but only 14,078 players live, number 32. Grow a Garden is the mirror image: 35,956,651,863 visits puts it number 4 on the all-time list, while 11,436,241 favorites has it at number 12 and 16,469 live has it at number 30. Both belong to families that reward long sessions rather than quick sessions, which is why their favorite counts stay high even on a quiet evening.

Why the two numbers drift apart in the first place

There is a structural reason favorites and live players rarely agree, and it comes down to how each one is produced. A favorite is a single irreversible action โ€” a player clicks once, the counter ticks, and nothing ever takes it back. Live players is a continuous measurement of a room that fills and empties. One number accumulates and never decays; the other is effectively a fresh sample every few minutes. Comparing them is comparing a ledger to a snapshot.

The practical consequence is that the favorites chart is sticky. Once a game has a large cumulative count, its rank barely moves no matter what happens to its player base this week. That is why MeepCity can hold 14,763,549 favorites at number 7 while sitting at 124 live players and dead last of 41, and why Jailbreak carries 18,675,985 favorites on only 5,971 concurrent players. Both numbers are accurate. They are answering different questions about different time spans.

There is a second structural effect worth knowing: favorites accumulate fastest in games with long retention curves. A game you return to for years contributes one favorite from you, but it also keeps you in the visits column indefinitely. That is exactly the pattern in the middle of the table โ€” Murder Mystery 2 at 31,055,698,073 visits, Blox Fruits at 64,820,861,493 and [๐ŸŒ—] Steal a Brainrot at 73,818,698,818 all show a favorites-to-visits relationship that only games with real staying power produce.

How to use the two rankings together

Read them as two ends of a spectrum. A game near the top of both charts is one you can walk into tonight and expect other players to be there โ€” Brookhaven, Murder Mystery 2 and Blox Fruits are the clearest examples, each holding the same rank on favorites and on live players. A game near the top of the favorites chart but low on live players is a historic title whose moment has passed or whose crowd arrives at a different time of day. And a game with a modest favorites count but a high live count is the one most worth watching, because it is either new or newly resurgent.

For genre-specific browsing rather than raw rankings, the simulator games on BloxBus page is a reasonable place to apply this. And if you want the terminology explained before you go further, the beginner guide from sign-up to your first Robux covers what each metric on a game page represents.

How concentrated the favorites are

Across all 41 tracked games the total favorite count was 376,024,050. The top ten games hold 71.5% of it and the top twelve 77.6%. That distribution is barely different from the live chart, where the top ten take 72.1% and the top twelve 76.6% โ€” so as a broad statement, the games that accumulate the most favorites are also usually the ones with the biggest audiences right now. The exceptions are the interesting part, and they are the reason we keep the live player count breakdown as a separate list.

For genre context, our piece on tycoon versus simulator and how to pick covers why certain categories accumulate favorites slowly, and if a game changed under a major update and you are not sure whether the older numbers still mean anything, our guide to reading Roblox update logs and seeing what actually changed covers that side.