loader
Game Reviews

Favourites Per Concurrent Player: The Ranking That Inverts the Live Table

Oct 24, 2026 Game Reviews
Favourites Per Concurrent Player: The Ranking That Inverts the Live Table

Favourites and concurrent players are two different verbs. Favouriting is something you do once, to remember a game. Playing is something you do repeatedly, and the directory's concurrency figure is a count of how many people are doing it at one instant. Dividing the first by the second produces a ratio that behaves unlike either input, and the resulting ranking is close to the inverse of the busiest-servers table.

The top ten by favourites per concurrent player

#GameFavouritesConcurrent playersFavourites per player
1meepcity14,766,646127116,273
2barrys-prison-run-obby105,254,29613,8347,608
3metro-life-city-rp67,719,40213,4145,048
4work-at-a-pizza-place13,631,2084,2173,232
5jailbreak18,688,2205,9713,130
6arsenal11,525,6794,0352,856
7royalehigh13,336,7916,6482,006
8pls-donate4,448,4082,9691,498
9szn-10-dragon-adventures14,561,32711,0371,319
10mvsd-murderers-vs-sheriffs-duels11,782,1539,7021,214
Cover art for a heavily favourited game with a moderate live population

What a high ratio actually means

meepcity tops this list with 14,766,646 favourites against 127 concurrent players — roughly 116,273 favourites for every person currently in the game. Read naively that looks like an extraordinary endorsement. Read correctly it is a statement about time: an enormous number of people bookmarked this game during a period when it was very popular, and almost none of them are playing it at the moment the snapshot was taken.

The directory holds 16,279,024,027 lifetime visits for the same game, which confirms the historical reading. The audience is real and was once very large. What the ratio captures is the gap between accumulated affection and present activity, and it is the single clearest available indicator of a game whose peak is behind it.

The bottom of the same ranking

The inverse is equally informative. The five lowest ratios in the synced set belong to adopt-me, anime-dice, huss-valley, launch-a-lucky-block, steal-an-egg, and the extreme case is Steal an Egg at roughly 7.0 favourites per concurrent player. That game carries 8,540,889 favourites — a large absolute number — against 1,212,468 concurrent players.

A low ratio does not mean a game is poorly regarded. It means the population is current: most of the people who care about it are in it right now, rather than having bookmarked it and moved on. For a player deciding where to find a populated server, the low end of this table is the more useful end. For someone researching which games have durable historical audiences, the high end is.

Why absolute favourites mislead

The directory's most-favourited game is barrys-prison-run-obby at 105,254,296, followed by Rivals at 95,689,324. Both are large absolute figures and both appear near the top of the plain favourites ranking. They sit at different places on the ratio table because their concurrency differs: Rivals has 209,281 players, which pulls its ratio down to roughly 457, while barrys-prison-run-obby has 13,834, giving about 7,608.

This is the general caution. A ranking built on a single cumulative counter will always favour older games, because cumulative counters only grow. Any comparison that mixes a cumulative field with a snapshot field — visits against concurrency, favourites against concurrency — inherits that bias in a measurable direction, and the ratio makes it visible rather than hiding it.

Comparing across categories

The effect is not uniform by genre. Within the simulator category, the eight synced games hold 52,104,718 favourites against 441,018 concurrent players, a category ratio of about 118. Shooter, with two games, runs far higher at roughly 503, driven almost entirely by one heavily-favourited entry. Two-game categories are too small for the category-level figure to mean much, which is a useful reminder that every aggregate here is only as stable as its sample.

Using the ratio in practice

Three rules make the number usable. First, treat it as a temporal signal, not a quality signal — it distinguishes current from historical audiences and says nothing about whether a game is good. Second, check the absolute concurrency before acting on it: a high ratio on 127 players is a very different proposition from the same ratio on fifty thousand. Third, read it alongside the visits-per-concurrent-player measure rather than instead of it, since the two ratios share a denominator and disagree in informative ways.

For the visits version of this calculation, the visits-per-concurrent-player breakdown covers all 72 games on the same basis, and the original favourites-versus-live-players comparison sets out why the two stored fields were separated in the first place.

The same games under three orderings

Nothing shows the point faster than ranking one set of games three ways. Take Rivals, Steal a Brainrot and MeepCity. Ordered by favourites, Rivals is far ahead at 95,689,324 against 29,608,594 and 14,766,646. Ordered by concurrent players, the order is close to unchanged for the first two — 209,281 against 155,946 — and MeepCity collapses to 127.

Ordered by the ratio, the list inverts completely: MeepCity moves from third to first, and the two games that lead on both absolute measures fall to the bottom. No arithmetic error is involved. The ratio divides a cumulative lifetime figure by an instantaneous one, so it rewards exactly the games that the absolute rankings penalise, and penalises exactly the ones they reward. Reading one ordering without the other gives you a confident and wrong picture of the directory.

Two worked examples

The top entry repays a closer look. MeepCity holds 16,279,024,027 lifetime visits, 14,766,646 favourites and 127 concurrent players, with an approval rating of 84.79% on 3,408,178 votes. Everything except the concurrency column describes a large and well-liked game. The ratio exists because the visits and favourites were accumulated over years while the concurrency figure was captured in one instant.

The second-placed entry makes a different point. Barry's Prison Run holds 105,254,296 favourites — the highest single total in the directory — against 13,834 concurrent players and 4,756,397,853 visits, with an approval rating of 60.66%. That last figure is markedly lower than MeepCity's, and it is the one place where the ratio and the approval measure agree: a game that large numbers of people bookmarked and comparatively few are playing also tends to carry a more divided vote. The correlation is loose and should not be over-read, but it is not noise either.

Scope

All 72 games here carry non-zero values for all three statistics. 21 additional titles in the directory have incomplete data and are excluded rather than imputed. Favourite counts are lifetime and additive; nothing is ever removed when a player unfavourites a game in the source data this directory synchronises, so the numerator should be read as "ever favourited" rather than "currently favourited".