Favourites and concurrent players measure opposite things. A favourite is a bookmark someone left once and mostly forgot; a concurrent player is a body in a server right now. Neither is better, but put them together as a ratio and you get something neither can show alone: how much remembered affection a game accumulates per person currently playing it. That ratio is the closest thing this directory has to a nostalgia index.
Two things changed since we last ran this table. First, the set of games carrying a complete statistic record grew from 41 titles in early October to 60 today, which pulled in a whole group of older, long-established games that had been sitting with empty numbers. Second, those additions are almost all high-ratio titles — games with big historical audiences and small current ones. The top of this ranking is therefore much more crowded with legacy games than it was a week ago.
| # | Game | Favourites | Players online | Favourites per player |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | meepcity | 14,766,160 | 154 | 95,884 |
| 2 | barrys-prison-run-obby | 105,245,079 | 18,272 | 5,760 |
| 3 | metro-life-city-rp | 67,604,918 | 15,550 | 4,348 |
| 4 | arsenal | 11,524,251 | 4,431 | 2,601 |
| 5 | jailbreak | 18,685,291 | 7,211 | 2,591 |
| 6 | work-at-a-pizza-place | 13,625,218 | 5,589 | 2,438 |
| 7 | royalehigh | 13,335,053 | 9,059 | 1,472 |
| 8 | driving-empire | 31,796,442 | 29,350 | 1,083 |
| 9 | mvsd-murderers-vs-sheriffs-duels | 11,724,835 | 11,946 | 981 |
| 10 | natural-disaster-survival | 11,908,364 | 13,062 | 912 |
MeepCity sits at 14,766,160 favourites against 154 players online, giving it roughly 95,884 favourites for every person in a server — a ratio about seventeen times larger than the runner-up. The game also carries 16,278,862,124 lifetime visits against that same tiny live audience, which is internally consistent: this is a title whose audience is enormous in total and almost entirely in the past. It is an extreme edge case and should be read as one.
The interesting entries are the ones below it. Barry's Prison Run Obby has 105,245,079 favourites — the largest absolute favourites total anywhere in the directory — while 18,272 people play it concurrently. Metro Life City RP holds 67,604,918 favourites on 15,550 concurrent. These are games people added to their list in large numbers and then did not return to this evening. None of this makes them bad games; it means their peak was somewhere else in time.
Nineteen of the games now carrying a complete record were absent from it in early October, and they are disproportionately represented near the top of this ratio. Natural Disaster Survival sits at 11,908,364 favourites against 13,062 concurrent players, a ratio of about 912. Murderers vs Sheriffs Duels shows 11,724,835 favourites on 11,946 players. Driving Empire holds 31,796,442 favourites against 29,350 concurrent. None of these could have appeared in the version of this table we published two weeks ago, because none of them had numbers attached.
That is worth stating plainly because it changes how the ranking should be read. This is not a list that has been stable and slowly decaying; it is a list whose membership changed shape this month, and any comparison against an older version of it is partly a comparison between different samples.
Among the ten highest ratios, almost every title has been on Roblox for years. Arsenal carries 11,524,251 favourites against 4,431 players and 6,317,798,638 lifetime visits. Jailbreak has 18,685,291 favourites against 7,211 concurrent. Work at a Pizza Place has 13,625,218 favourites with 5,589 playing. These three between them account for a large share of the total favourites in the whole directory while contributing a rounding error to tonight's concurrency.
You can see the same shape from the other direction using the obby category: Tower of Hell has 29,189,366,981 lifetime visits and 12,065,402 favourites but only 15,805 concurrent players, and it is one of only two titles the obby genre page currently files. Both of the games on that page are old, both are heavily favourited, and neither is anywhere near the live top ten. That is the obby genre's situation in this directory, stated honestly rather than dressed up.
The lowest ratios among games with at least a thousand players online are dominated by titles whose audiences are large and immediate. Steal an Egg — the concurrency leader we covered separately — has 8,124,148 favourites against 1,833,300 live, roughly 4 favourites per player. Big audiences do not have to favourite anything to show up. Adopt Me is the most extreme case and also a data oddity we keep flagging: it reports 65,311 concurrent players against 728 lifetime visits, a combination that cannot both be right, so we use it as an example of what an inconsistent record looks like rather than as evidence of anything.
The raw favourites leaderboard is dominated by whichever games accumulated the most bookmarks, and because favourites never expire, it barely moves. We wrote about that inertia in a comparison of favourites against live players, and the conclusion still holds: the favourites list is effectively frozen, while the concurrency list reshuffles every night. Dividing one by the other gives you a number that responds to both.
It also explains why a game can be enormous and quiet at the same time. If you are reading a favourites per player breakdown for the first time, the single most useful takeaway is that absence from a live ranking is not decline. MeepCity is not failing; it is remembered.
One more practical use: when you are choosing an older game to revisit, a high ratio is a reasonable signal that enough people liked it to keep it bookmarked, and Arsenal's presence on the Arsenal codes page alongside its full record makes it easy to check the current state of a legacy title before you install anything.
It cannot tell you when the favourites were placed. There is no timestamp on a favourite in this data, so a game favourited hard in 2019 and a game favourited hard last week look identical here. The visits-per-concurrent view we maintain separately, discussed in a piece on what that ratio reveals, suffers from the same limitation from the other side. Together they narrow the question down, but neither can date an audience.
What the pair does establish is this: in a directory of 60 games carrying 748,621,628 favourites between them, remembered affection and present-day attendance are two entirely different leaderboards, and almost no game leads both.