Obby and roleplay are the two genres most new players get told about first, and they reward completely different things. One is a test of execution with a fixed route; the other is an open social space with no defined objective. Comparing them with real numbers rather than vibes is the fastest way to work out which suits you, and the BloxBus directory has enough of both to do that comparison properly.
Right now the obby category listing contains 2 titles and the roleplay category listing contains 5. Both are subsets of the 76 games carrying complete statistics, so every figure below comes from the same snapshot taken today.
| Game | Live now | Total visits | Favourites | Approval |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| +1 Speed Keyboard Escape | 21,091 | 6,590,604,683 | 7,196,445 | 96.7% |
| Tower of Hell | 11,043 | 29,262,372,076 | 12,088,553 | 73.6% |
Obby games are small and punchy. Together these 2 titles account for 32,134 concurrent players, 35,852,976,759 lifetime visits and 19,284,998 favourites, with a combined approval rate of 88.3% across 16,345,116 votes.
Tower of Hell is the archetype. It holds 29,262,372,076 lifetime visits - the largest visit count either side of this comparison - against only 11,043 concurrent players. Divide one by the other and you get 2,649,857 visits for every person currently in a server. That is the profile of a game people play in short bursts: launch, climb, fall, quit, come back tomorrow. It is also why the Tower of Hell guide is organised around stage-by-stage technique rather than long-term progression systems.
+1 Speed Keyboard Escape shows a different balance. Its 6,590,604,683 visits against 21,091 concurrent players give a ratio of 312,484, and it carries an approval rate of 96.7% - higher than any other game in either of these two sets. High approval plus a big catalogue of accumulated visits is the signature of a game people finish and recommend.
| Game | Live now | Total visits | Favourites | Approval |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Murder Mystery 2 | 263,963 | 31,834,248,204 | 24,667,599 | 90.8% |
| Brookhaven 🏡RP | 255,765 | 88,909,886,510 | 30,683,521 | 85.9% |
| [🎃] Adopt Me! | 65,311 | 728 | 1,255 | 27.3% |
| Dress To Impress ⭐ | 54,495 | 11,241,272,564 | 7,678,942 | 90.6% |
| MeepCity | 125 | 16,279,100,512 | 14,766,582 | 84.8% |
Roleplay looks completely different. These 5 titles carry 639,659 concurrent players - 19.9 times the obby figure - alongside 148,264,508,518 lifetime visits and 77,797,899 favourites, at a combined 88.4% approval.
The defining trait is that roleplay games hold people. Brookhaven 🏡RP carries 88,909,886,510 lifetime visits - the single largest visit count in the entire directory - and 255,765 concurrent players, giving a ratio of 347,623 visits per live player. Compare that with Tower of Hell's 2,649,857 and the difference is the whole argument: the obby has roughly 7.6 times more stored history per person playing right now. Roleplay sessions are longer and undramatic; obby sessions are short and repeated.
Murder Mystery 2 sits at 263,963 concurrent players with 24,667,599 favourites and a 90.8% approval rate. It is also the Murder Mystery 2 genre guide example of a structured round-based roleplay rather than an open one - which is worth knowing before you expect Brookhaven-style wandering.
[🎃] Adopt Me! appears in the roleplay set with 65,311 concurrent players but only 728 total visits and 1,255 favourites. Those three numbers cannot all be right simultaneously, and the directory does not hide that - it publishes what Roblox returns. Use Adopt Me as a live-presence signal and ignore its odometer.
MeepCity inverts the problem: 16,279,100,512 lifetime visits against 125 concurrent players. Both figures are internally consistent, and both are real. Neither should be used as evidence about how busy MeepCity is today.
The cleanest way to say all of the above is that these two genres are built around different units of play. An obby session is one attempt. A roleplay session is an afternoon with no defined end. Every number in the tables above follows from that single distinction, and once you internalise it the statistics stop looking contradictory.
Short sessions produce huge visit counts and modest concurrent occupancy, because each visit is brief and each player leaves quickly, freeing the slot for the next one. Long sessions produce the opposite: fewer launches, but every launch occupies a server slot for an hour or more. This is why Tower of Hell can carry more lifetime visits than Brookhaven 🏡RP per live player by a factor of 7.6 and still be the quieter place to log into on a weeknight. Neither game is "bigger"; they are counting different things.
It also explains the favourite patterns. Players bookmark an obby to come back and beat a stage. Players bookmark a roleplay game because it is where their friends are. The first is a task list, the second is an address book, and over months the two accumulate very differently.
Update logging adds a third dimension. Dress To Impress ⭐ has 19 tracked update entries in the directory, the largest single figure anywhere in the directory, against MeepCity with 1. That tells you the roleplay category is not uniformly maintained - it spans actively-developed titles and dormant ones side by side, and the visit counts alone would never reveal it.
One honest caveat: these entries record when this directory started logging each game, not when the game was released. MeepCity's single entry with a first-tracked date of Jan 12, 2026 reflects the directory's logging window, not the game's age.
If you want a defined goal, short sessions and visible improvement, obby is the better fit, and its higher combined approval rate of 88.3% against roleplay's 88.4% suggests people get what they expected from it. If you want to spend an unstructured hour in a populated space talking to people, roleplay holds far more players at any given moment - this set alone accounts for 19.5% of everyone currently playing across the whole directory.
The honest answer is that most people settle into one and visit the other, so it is worth reading both category pages rather than picking once. The Dress to Impress guide is a useful middle case - round-structured like Murder Mystery 2, but social like Brookhaven - and it carries 54,495 concurrent players with a 90.6% approval rate. For a wider genre-level comparison, our explainer on choosing between obby and roleplay from the data takes the same approach across earlier snapshots.